Skip to content
Lobster Shack exterior on Overseas Highway.

Menu

Browse the seafood restaurant menu Islamorada guests order from at Lobster Shack.

Seafood restaurant menu in Islamorada

Lobster Shack’s seafood restaurant menu Islamorada visitors browse is arranged by section, so the choices stay clear as soon as the page opens. The layout moves through Lobster Shack Menu, Drinks, Coffee Menu, Sandwiches, and Cafe Cubano. That structure matters here. It shows a place where the board does the work before the order starts.

The drinks side includes Soda Water, Malta, Bottle Water, and Mamey Milkshake. The coffee side adds Americano, Cappuccino, and Colada, so a quick stop can lean cold or hot. Sandwiches sit beside Cuban-style items, with Mahi Mahi Sandwich, Midnight Sandwich, Family 14 Inch Pizza Cubana, and Fried Mozzarella among the named choices. Key Lime Pie Bar rounds out the sweeter end of the menu. The result is a menu that moves from simple drinks to stronger, more filling plates without losing its shape.

Simple dining area with a beach-town feel.

Dishes

A few named dishes show the range on the board.

  • Jarritos
    Jarritos
    $5.00
  • Maine Lobster Rolls
    Maine Lobster Rolls

    5oz of delicious lobster on a butter toasted bun

    $28.50
  • Café Cubano Colada
    Café Cubano Colada
  • Conch Fritters
    Conch Fritters
  • Avocado Crab Salad
    Avocado Crab Salad
  • Lobster blt Roll
    Lobster blt Roll